Joe Gatto, James "Murr" Murray, Brian "Q" Quinn, and Sal Vulcano

Capitalizing on Sal's germaphobia, his friends forced him to sift through heaps of garbage to find a fake missing item.

Season 1 introduced the simple, game-show-adjacent structure that kept viewers hooked from week to week:

: Often assigned the most awkward social tasks; he once ran for Congress as an April Fool's joke.

The Complete Guide to Impractical Jokers Season 1: The Birth of Prank TV Royalty

The guys try to read bizarre, self-written stories to patrons in a bookstore.

If you’re new to Impractical Jokers , start here. If you’re a longtime fan, it’s a nostalgic trip back to simpler times—before the cruise ships and the movie, when four friends from Staten Island just wanted to make each other squirm for our amusement.

8.5/10 awkward stares.

(Rings bell aggressively while looking at the pastry case.)

The Birth of Cringe Comedy: Why Impractical Jokers Season 1 Still Rules Television

After years of performing live improv and producing YouTube sketches, Murr pitched a new concept to TruTV: a hidden-camera show where the joke was on the prankster, not the public. TruTV ordered a pilot, shot entirely on iPhones to save money. The network greenlit the first season, and television history was made. The Rules of the Game

Since this is Season 1, the punishments were simpler but brutal.

One of the most iconic early bits involving "Don't stop, let's go."